Opinions

Negotiating Our Sub-Humanity

 Dr. Musa Shihadeh,  Kana’an Electronic Bulletin, kanaanonline.org     (05-01-2005)

Back to Opinions Page

 

Last month, Mr. Sharon has finally declared his plan for final "peace" and not in vague terms. He stated unequivocally, that any future peace will not include the right of return (ROR), or the return to the 1967 borders. Further more such declarations are totally supported by the US, the superpower, who conjured the so-called "Road Map".

 

Yet, with naïve and persistent obstinacy, our "glorious" leadership is still talking about peaceful negotiations! Negotiate what! is a question that no one in the leadership can explain.

 

Mr. Sharon's position shows clearly that the minimal national aspirations of the Palestinian people will never be fulfilled under any peace formula. Yet Mr. Mahmud Abbas, the head of the PLO, aside from criticizing such position, has not come up with any other option that might lead to the fulfillment of the Palestinian legitimate national rights. On Al-Jazeera interview on 19 December 2004, Mr. Mahmud Abbas re-confirmed that no positive expectations are awaiting any possible peace negotiations with the Israeli Likud government, yet he insisted that one should try such process to test Israeli intentions!

 

My God! Are we saying that we do not fathom such declared Israeli intentions?  

 

If the Israeli unacceptable final position has been declared time after time, then there is nothing left for any mutual process except the travesty of negotiating our sub-humanity, our humiliation, our total surrender and our deprivation of our national and human rights.

 

I have never read in annals of history that a certain leadership will negotiate their own bondage to an aggressive oppressor. Yet our leadership are naively preparing for such a humiliating process. Why negotiate if the outcome has been set by Israel that would not depart from the miserable status-quo? Are we going to ever wake up to the fact that only resistance, all forms of resistance, will ever achieve our national rights? Why then are we not exercising such option?  

 

The apparent difference between the PLO and the Islamic armed resistance groups was on strategy and not on goals, as they both differed on the route that should be espoused to achieve total liberation. If the final outcome of any peace negotiations, which has been already set by Sharon ahead of time, does not come, not even close, to the minimal demands of the Palestinian legitimate goals, then any future negotiations with Sharon will border on sheer theatrics.

 

The Palestinian leadership pragmatism in dealing with Israel has been torn to pieces, when the peaceful route through negotiations has been totally closed. Keeping this in mind, it would seem very logical that the difference in strategy among the Palestinian factions should dissolve rendering the enigma of future strategy into a one clear route namely resistance to occupation, all forms of resistance.

 

The Palestinian election process in this case could not be explained except as a new Israeli ploy to divert our attention from our national goals. What is the meaning of a Palestinian authority when such authority is under a foreign power? How can an authority deliberate its duties toward its people if another authority dictates the terms, especially when the foreign authority has declared its intentions ahead of time to continue its policy of subjugating the oppressed?

 

Unity of strategy has not been drawn by the prudence of our different factions, but unfortunately by Sharon himself. He is telling us indirectly that the peace process will lead to a dead end, and then it should behoove our leadership to get this message from our enemies and start unification for the purpose of resistance, in all its forms, and the continuation of the Intifada.

 

It's time for our leadership to resign from shouldering a responsibility they are not capable of, and leave the stage to a younger leadership who were not intoxicated by power, corruption and delusion of peace. Peace will never arrive on an Israeli or American tank, but by the Palestinian martyrs who are ready to sacrifice their lives on the alter of freedom. No one ever said that the road for freedom is embedded with roses but by the blood of our fighters for liberation and independence.

 

With all our weakness notwithstanding, we should not panic under the Israeli military power, as no peace can arrive to the entire area without the Palestinian card. We should never throw this card into the garbage can offered by Israel and the US. We should resist and resist so that we would not be labeled by history as people who would relinquish their rights under the heels of a cruel oppressor. If peaceful negotiations will render us people without honor, freedom or dignity, then we should die while fighting for our cause, as death for freedom is superior to life without honor. 

 

 

 

__________________________________________________________________________________

Home - About Us - Publications - Editorials - Studies - Documents - Opinions - Reports - Refugees - Palestine - Cartoons - Zionism - Links

 

Copyright is protected for BAHETH for STUDIES.

This web is best viewed with screen resolution 800*600.
For problems or questions and suggestions regarding this web please contact us.